A significant milestone has been reached in the campaign to make children’s safety the priority in family court decisions.
In October, Women’s Aid Chief Executive Farah Nazeer, Survivor Ambassador Claire Throssell MBE and Marie Tidball MP met with Prime Minister Andy Burnham, alongside Minister for Victims Alex Davies-Jones and Minister for Courts Sarah Sackman, following the passing of the Courts and Tribunals Bill’s Third Reading in the House of Commons.
The Bill includes a provision to remove the legal presumption of parental involvement in a child’s life – a change known as Jack and Paul’s Law, in memory of Claire’s two sons, who were tragically killed by their abusive father.
Why is this change important?
Under the current law, family courts are required to presume that a child’s welfare will be furthered by the involvement of both parents, unless there is evidence to show otherwise. Although the presumption can be challenged where there is evidence of risk, concerns have been raised that it has contributed to a pro-contact culture in family courts, with children and non-abusive parents not always being adequately protected.
Removing the presumption means courts will focus on the individual circumstances of each child, with their welfare and safety at the centre of decisions about parental involvement.
For women and children experiencing domestic abuse, this is particularly important. Perpetrators can use family court proceedings and child contact arrangements as a way to continue abuse after separation. The change aims to help prevent the family court system from being used in this way.
A campaign in memory of Jack and Paul
Claire Throssell has campaigned for more than a decade, alongside Women’s Aid, for changes to the family courts system.
Her sons, Jack and Paul, were killed by their abusive father following contact arrangements authorised by the family court, despite Claire’s repeated warnings about the risk he posed.
The campaign to repeal the presumption of parental involvement is therefore not only about changing legislation; it is about ensuring that children’s experiences, voices and safety are properly considered, and that other families do not experience the same tragedy.
Women’s Aid has highlighted that, over the past 30 years, 67 children have been killed by a parent who was also a perpetrator of domestic abuse in unsafe child contact arrangements.
An important step, but more work remains
The passing of the Bill’s Third Reading in the House of Commons marks a major step forward after years of campaigning. However, the Bill must still complete its passage through Parliament before the change becomes law.
Women’s Aid has also called for mandatory specialist domestic and sexual abuse training for judges, recognising that changing legislation alone will not immediately address the culture and practices that have developed within the family courts.
The campaign’s message is clear: children’s safety and wellbeing must come first. Decisions about their lives must be based on their individual needs and circumstances, with domestic abuse and the risks posed by perpetrators properly understood and taken into account.
Read Women’s Aid’s statement on the Courts and Tribunals Bill
